Machon Daniel Institutions

 
 
Home ] Contact Us ] Approbations ]

 

Mysterious Tomatoes

Original publication date:

Yerucham from Neve Ya'acov asks:

A tomato plant has recently started growing out of our concrete garden path. Are these tomatoes permitted or do they fall under the category of s'fichin?

At this time of year, all tomatoes grown on Jewish-owned land are forbidden because of s'fichin. Even if they grew spontaneously (for example, from tomato seed which scattered in the wind) they are still forbidden. However, our Sages did not apply the prohibition to (a) species which are not usually cultivated or (b) places which are not usually cultivated. Thus, wild edible plants found growing in a forest are not subject to this prohibition. Similarly, if plants suddenly sprout of a concrete path or yard they are also permitted, even if the species is generally cultivated. Not only may you eat the fruits of your tomato plant, but you can also water the plant and perform whatever rabbinically-prohibited work is required to keep it alive. The tomatoes obviously have kedushas shvi'is.

  Contact Rabbi Yoel Moore via Emaill

MDShmita is written by Rabbi Yoel Moore
Layout & Design: Lev Seltzer
Rabbi Yona Vogel, Rosh Yeshiva, Machon Daniel

 

 

If you enjoy this site, consider making a tax-deductible donation to Machon Daniel.

  Copyright © 2010 Machon Daniel Institutions.  Articles and publications may be reprinted only with written permission from Machon Daniel
Please Contact Us if you have questions or comments about this web site.
 


  Last modified: October 17, 2009