Machon Daniel Institutions

 
 
Home ] Contact Us ] Approbations ]

 

Melon Melancholy

Original publication date:

Avi from New York asks:

My wife is crazy about melons. Our local fruit store had a special offer on "Spanish" honeydew melons, which is her favourite. I bought a large quantity of this luscious fruit as a treat for our wedding anniversary. When I got home, I noticed that the label on each and every melon said, "Made in Israel" and it's the sh'mittah year! I think I can cope with my wife's disappointment, but what should I do with all these melons?

Avi, all is not lost! Melons from Israel have the status of vegetables and thus could be subject to the prohibition of s'fichin if they were grown on Jewish-owned land within the halachic borders of Eretz Yisroel. They may then not be eaten and must be left to spoil. (It was also forbidden to export them from Eretz Yisroel). However, Israeli melons could also come from other sources. If they were grown on land owned by non-Jews, they do have kedushas shvi'is according to some opinions (and should not have been exported), but may certainly be eaten according to all opinions. Another possibility is that they were grown by Jews in the Southern Aravah area (south of the 30th parallel). In that case, they would not have kedushas shvi'is at all, since this area is considered to be outside the halachic boundaries of Eretz Yisroel. Go back to the fruit store and try to find out where the melons really come from. In any event, you should rebuke the storeowner for his deception!
  Contact Rabbi Yoel Moore via Emaill

MDShmita is written by Rabbi Yoel Moore
Layout & Design: Lev Seltzer
Rabbi Yona Vogel, Rosh Yeshiva, Machon Daniel

 

 

If you enjoy this site, consider making a tax-deductible donation to Machon Daniel.

  Copyright © 2010 Machon Daniel Institutions.  Articles and publications may be reprinted only with written permission from Machon Daniel
Please Contact Us if you have questions or comments about this web site.
 


  Last modified: October 17, 2009