Machon Daniel Institutions

 
 
Home ] Contact Us ] Approbations ]

 

A GUEST IN YERUSHALAYIM

Original publication date:

Menachem from Bnei Brak asks: 

We follow the ruling of the Chazon Ish, z’tl, that produce grown by non-Jews on non-Jewish owned land in Eretz Yisroel does have kedushas shvi’is. How do I acquire such produce in Yerushalayim, where the prevalent custom is that non-Jewish produce has no sanctity?

Let me first explain your question. One may not trade in produce which has kedushas shvi’is. The custom in Jerusalem is to treat non-Jewish produce as having no sanctity. Accordingly, it may be sold in the usual way. However, in Bnei Brak such produce is considered as having kedushas shvi’is. It may therefore not be sold in the usual way. Since the storeowner is permitted to purchase this produce from the non-Jew, the accepted method of acquisition is that the customer appoints him as his agent to buy from the non-Jew. However, a store following Minhag Yerushalayim (the Jerusalem custom) may not have this facility available. What options are then open to one who follows the ruling of the Chazon Ish? Firstly, there are those who are of the opinion that the prohibition of trading is on the seller, but not on the purchaser. Since the seller is just following his local custom, one could argue that by purchasing from him in the usual way one is not causing him to do anything wrong. Nevertheless, a further method is available (according to many opinions), which will avoid this problem. This is known as havlo’oh (absorption). It works as follows. One purchases an item which definitely does not have kedushas shvi’is (for example, sixth year produce) together with the non-Jewish produce. A higher than usual payment is made for this ordinary produce, and the kedushas shvi’is non-Jewish produce is given for free. Thus, one has not purchased the non-Jewish produce which has kedushas shvi’is according to the custom of one’s hometown.

  Contact Rabbi Yoel Moore via Emaill

MDShmita is written by Rabbi Yoel Moore
Layout & Design: Lev Seltzer
Rabbi Yona Vogel, Rosh Yeshiva, Machon Daniel

 

 

If you enjoy this site, consider making a tax-deductible donation to Machon Daniel.

  Copyright © 2010 Machon Daniel Institutions.  Articles and publications may be reprinted only with written permission from Machon Daniel
Please Contact Us if you have questions or comments about this web site.
 


  Last modified: October 17, 2009