Machon Daniel Institutions

 
 
Home ] Contact Us ] Approbations ]

 

Fresh Tomato Soup

Original publication date:

Sammy from Ramat Eshkol asks: 

My wife makes a delicious soup out of fresh tomatoes. Can she prepare the soup with sh’mittah tomatoes? Can she peel the tomatoes before putting them into the soup?

Tomatoes are generally eaten either raw or cooked. It is therefore permitted to cook them in a soup. However, since only a minority of people prepare tomato soup from fresh tomatoes, one must ensure that the tomatoes are eventually eaten. This would not be the case with onions used to flavour meat or fish. Since it is common practice to use onions for this purpose, there is no need to eat the onions after using them to flavour another dish. It is permitted to use the onions for this purpose even if this will render them unfit for eating since they have lost their taste.

Regarding peeling tomatoes, since tomatoes are generally eaten with their peel, one may not remove the peel. People will not eat the peel on its own. Such removal prevents the peel from being eaten and is therefore considered a form of destruction. However, if a thicker layer of tomato flesh is removed together with the peel, this is permitted. We view such an act as merely separating one part of the tomato flesh from the other. One may leave the tomato peel to spoil, together with the attached fruit.

  Contact Rabbi Yoel Moore via Emaill

MDShmita is written by Rabbi Yoel Moore
Layout & Design: Lev Seltzer
Rabbi Yona Vogel, Rosh Yeshiva, Machon Daniel

 

 

If you enjoy this site, consider making a tax-deductible donation to Machon Daniel.

  Copyright © 2010 Machon Daniel Institutions.  Articles and publications may be reprinted only with written permission from Machon Daniel
Please Contact Us if you have questions or comments about this web site.
 


  Last modified: October 17, 2009